It was founded by musicians from the late-1990's hardcore scene: guitarists Neeraj Kane and Jay Jancetic, and bassist Geoff Reu, with drummer Tony Tintari of Shai Hulud joining the group a few months later.
Classically trained singer Emily Schambra joined about a year later, which was followed by the recording of a demo and them beginning to play live shows.
AllMusic reviewer Stewart Mason shared this sentiment, calling it "competently executed post-hardcore" and "strictly for serious fans interested in Holy Roman Empire's growing pains".
AllMusic praised the vocals and the production, and said that it is "tuneful without being blatantly commercial, thoughtful without being ickily emo, and a generally rocking good listen".
[5] Brian Shultz of Punknews.org stated "it's as solid a debut full-length can usually be produced; its style is a pleasant surprise considering its members' preceding projects; and it could be a great breakout release for Hewhocorrupts, Inc".