The main sanctuary is a stone structure, built out of locally quarried red and purple marble.

It has high-style Gothic Revival features including a buttressed square tower with a crenellated flat top, and a large Gothic-arched stained glass window at the center of the street-facing facade.

The present Carpenter Gothic parish hall was built in 1876 to a design by Ira D. Hatch, a local resident.

The town and congregation both experienced significant growth in the following decades, and the new stone sanctuary was added in 1909-10, a gift from Rev.

[3] It was designed by Louis S. Newton of Hartford, Vermont, and is a prominent local example of a High Gothic Revival style.