But perhaps, in this age of acceleration, amid a pop blizzard of viral memes and instant digital fame, the slow maturing of a truly substantial talent is something to really celebrate".

[10] Eric R. Danton of Paste stated, "Like Harris, Andrews' voice can ring out with force of feeling even at its softest, and relying on nuance instead of vocal pyrotechnics turns the song into an intimate confession.

[7] Harrison Moore of GIGsoup considered that "Courtney Marie Andrews returns with a coming of age album, rich with introspective lyrics and beautifully arranged".

[8] Hal Horowitz of American Songwriter wrote, "Support by sparse but not stark backing, make these ballads glow and shine with a low key luster".

[3] Loz Etheridge of God Is in the TV stated, "Perhaps the most obvious comparison in terms of modern contemporaries is the impeccable Swedish duo First Aid Kit".