After discussing the film, Scheer reads "second opinions" in the form of five-star reviews posted online by Amazon.com users.

Some full episodes are recorded in front of a live audience and include a question and answer session and original "second opinion" theme songs sung by fans.

: Origin Stories, author Blake J. Harris would interview people involved with the movies discussed on the podcast.

Guests on the show included director Mel Brooks, who served as executive producer on Solarbabies,[12] and screenwriter Dan Gordon, who wrote Surf Ninjas.

[14] Unlike HDTGM?, Unspooled looks at films deemed good enough for the updated 2007 edition of the AFI Top 100.

by Mantzoukas and Raphael, who are comically annoyed at how they were not invited to host the podcast, instead being subjected to the bad films that HDTGM covers.

[15] The podcast was later changed to Get Played, focusing on multiple aspects of video games and deviating from the original format.

The show then ends with a reading of comments found on AlloCiné, the biggest French-speaking cinema website, or from Amazon.