Mind (2014) and rose to popularity from releasing a metal cover of Taylor Swift's "Blank Space" as a single, which eventually was certified platinum in the US.

The band found success with their original material as well, with the singles "Breaking Down" and "Hurricane" performing well on rock radio,[1] the single "Bow Down" being nominated for the Grammy Award for Best Metal Performance in 2019, and Trauma being nominated for the Grammy Award for Best Rock Album the same year.

[13] On May 17, 2016, the band announced their headlining Strike the Match Tour throughout the summer,[14][15] with special guests The White Noise, My Enemies & I, and Bad Seed Rising.

[18] On July 19, 2016, I Prevail announced through social media that they would be supporting Pierce the Veil alongside Neck Deep on the Journey's Made to Destroy tour from September to October 2016.

[20] On September 28, 2016, the band released their third single "Come and Get It" through Short.Fast.Loud, an Australian-based punk and hardcore radio show on youth station Triple J.

[23] In late March/early April 2017, the band had their first major overseas headline tour, which included sold-out shows across Australia.

[22] On August 8, 2017, I Prevail announced a fall-winter headline tour with The Word Alive, We Came as Romans, and Escape the Fate.

[29] Along with the new single being released, Gabe Helguera was made a full time member of the band although Eli Clark was absent from both new music videos.

[35][36] On August 6, 2019, A Day to Remember announced that I Prevail, Beartooth, & Can't Swim would be supporting them on their "Degenerates" headlining tour.

[37][38] In November 2019, the band received two Grammy Nominations; the Best Rock Album for Trauma, and the Best Metal Performance for "Bow Down".

In an Instagram post, Burkheiser stated that he was recovering from surgery for a rare condition known as Eagle syndrome.

[63] James Christopher Monger of AllMusic described the band's sound as a "blistering blend of metalcore, pop-punk, and post-hardcore that invokes names like Bring Me the Horizon, We Came as Romans, and A Day to Remember.