I Stole Your Animal is the first full-length album by Care Bears on Fire.

[3] The band was in middle school when the album was released.

[4] PopMatters called the album "cheerful garage pop-punk," writing that it was "not entirely without charm.

"[3] SFGate called it "rough-around-the-edges, early-style American punk.

"[5] The Austin Chronicle wrote that Care Bears on Fire "shred precociously on smart, snappy songs like 'Met You on MySpace.