This was the first Polar Bear record that was produced and mixed entirely by Rochford, giving him more creative control of the overall sound of the album.

[1] “For me, this album is about heart, and I hope that when people listen to it, it makes them feel theirs", says Rochford about the album, "I want people to let go, I want it to be an experience.” [2] In Each And Every One was widely celebrated and made an impact with its vast sonic departure from the group's previous release Peepers.

[6] Paul Tingen of Sound on Sound noted that In Each and Every One "takes the listener on an exotic journey through ambient music, drum & bass, electronic experimentation, free jazz, calypso, industrial, psychedelic rock and more, all held in a modern‑sounding production that has much more depth, variety and presence than that of Peeper.

"[8] On the Metacritic website, which aggregates various media and press reviews and assigns a normalised rating out of 100, In Each And Every One received a score of 78.

[3] Polar Bear also were shortlisted for the 2014 Mercury Music Prize for In Each And Every One,[9] garnering them extra media coverage and a wider audience.