Samantha (Maggie Lawson) is about to be married to Carlos (James Roday), a man whom she loves deeply despite the fact that she has only known him for a short while.

Ruthie passes Samantha a note that was given to her from Father Chris (William B. Davis), the reverend.

She opens the letter and finds a typewritten note which reads: "The person you are marrying is a serial killer."

Elsewhere, the person in the red scarf enters a room filled with human heads in jars and bloody corpses.

[2][3] Slant felt that the episode's initial conceit of a woman receiving a note stating that she was marrying a serial killer could have been "a pretty good hook for a Hitchcockian melodrama along the lines of Suspicion were Salva actually interested in telling that particular story" but that "it quickly becomes obvious that the whole thing is just a setup for a lame and illogical twist ending.

"[4] Dread Central was critical in their review, as they felt that "this series continues to demonstrate the biggest fault of Masters of Horror: Horror anthologies are best suited to half-hour episodes a la Tales From The Crypt instead of the bloated hour-long format.