In an interview with Metal Hammer UK, Chris "Motionless" Cerulli states that although he has enjoyed working within the metalcore genre, he and the band aim to develop their sound to prevent it from becoming too generic; Infamous has been their first step toward achieving this goal.

[5] In the same article, Cerulli talks about the sound on Creatures stating that their aim was to "take the (metalcore) genre and put twists on it and re-invent what it means to be this sort of band."

"Sick from the Melt", the thirteenth track on the deluxe version of the album, features Trevor Friedrich, percussionist of Combichrist and the vocalist of The Witch Was Right, now-percussionist Brandon Richter's former band.

Alternative Press gave Infamous 5 out of 5 stars, saying that "Motionless In White have definitely proven their point and carried it out well" and that it sounds similar to Marilyn Manson and label mates The Word Alive.

[7] Revolver said Infamous "rages like Bleeding Through, and stomps like vintage Manson", and "displays a compelling [musical] range for a young band", giving the album a 3.5 out of 5.