[6] Infinite Craft was made by Neal Agarwal, a software developer based in New York City.

In an interview, Agarwal said that he has been developing games since the age of nine and that he thinks "There should be more people creating fun stuff on the web."

One of the site's first games, Spend Bill Gates' Money, received attention with over 80 million page views.

According to Agarwal, the game received over thirty thousand views in the first month[12] and over 300 million recipes are created each day.

[6] This has caused the website's servers to overload, and Agarwal had to petition the hosting service provider to increase its bandwidth.

[6] Rock Paper Shotgun's Graham Smith praised how the game was "glorious, time-stealing fun to try", commenting how "the real joy comes" when a player finds a simple way to create an element.