While they had left as champions, their first year back proved much less successful as they finished fourth out of four teams with a 3-10-2 record.
[1] While St. Leo’s, their nemesis for the previous two SLSL seasons, were now in the Federal Park League, Innisfails was still unable to top the standings, finishing second to the Columbus Club in 1913-1914.
This merger brought Ben Millers into the league and both Innisfails and St. Leo’s found themselves battling for second behind the new team.
In 1920, Innisfails lost to eventual champion Ben Millers in the second round of the National Challenge Cup.
Matt Diedrichsen of Innisfails was the only player outside of the northeast U.S. called into the team for its tour of Scandinavia.