"[6] Gordon Goble of CNET Gamecenter stated that the game "provides only a marginally entertaining experience that lacks much of the thrill of the actual sport".

[5] Mark Kanarick of AllGame wrote, "Though fun at times, Disc Golf stands as an average game at best.

"[9] Steinberg also criticized the multiplayer option, writing that "the chances of finding a buddy that owns the game, let alone wants to play it, are slim to none.

Kanarick also stated that players would have no choice but to use the mulligan option repeatedly because the discs "perform so unexpectedly at times".

"[9] Goble considered the graphics outdated and wrote that the game was "not ugly per se, but the environments are motionless aside from your flying disc".

[7] Kanarick praised the simple graphics, writing that the backgrounds "are nice enough to maintain interest but not too detailed as to take away from the gameplay.

[6] Silverstein also considered the sound to be possibly the worst aspect of the game, stating that it "is practically nonexistent most of the time except for a couple of chirping birds.

[9] Colin Williamson of PC Gamer wrote, "The only thing that makes the game worth playing – but only once – is the amazingly bad commentary.