[4] It was also performed at the British music chart television programme Top of the Pops.

Larry Flick from Billboard wrote that Todd Terry "reminds club-land of his ability to construct catchy ditties that offer no apologies for their straightforward pop feel."

He described the track as an "appealing single [...] bolstered by a seductively breathy vocal by disco-era diva Shannon", and also complimented its "pleasantly repetitive hook".

[5] British magazine Music Week gave the song four out of five, adding, "More classy, uplifting garage from Todd The God featuring big vocals by Shannon.

"[6] Also Chris Finan from the RM Dance Update rated "It's Over Love" four out of five.