Charlie Hudson and Anna Penn are staying at The Plaza in Manhattan as their respective fiancés Claire and David are in Europe for work and they are left to start wedding preparations.
That night, as she falls asleep in the tub, her overflowing water seeps onto Charlie's bed below, so he goes upstairs with maintenance.
Separating to get their bridal party gifts, they couldn't help but notice the salespeople's negative views of marriage.
She reveals that she teaches fourth grade, and he explains that he'd quit the police force six months ago, as he wasn't able to prevent a child from committing suicide.
They come across an old contact of Charlie's who's gone a bit loopy after his divorce, then pop in to briefly visit the priest officiating his wedding.
Claire leaves early the next day, Charlie is encouraged to seek Anna out and confess his feelings.
They find both of the officers; Henry explains he is on the wagon and was too embarrassed to call Tracey and they finally kiss.