Renfroe earned a Women's College World Series All-Tournament team honors in 2010.
Renfroe was also named to the Women's College World Series All-Tournament team with a 2–2 record in the tournament.
She had a 25–9 record in her Junior campaign and helped the team to a Women's College World Series appearance.
In addition to her 25 wins, Renfroe was named to the SEC spring Academic Honor Roll.
Renfroe helped the Lady Vols finish runner-up in the Women's College World Series, with a 1–1 record, including a win over Texas in the Semifinals to move Tennessee into the championship series against the Oklahoma Sooners.