Noll did not receive a Division I baseball scholarship out of Charlotte High School in Punta Gorda, Florida, where he hit just one home run during his playing career.

[9] Noll chose to sign with the Nationals[2] and was named among the organization's Minor League Baseball All-Stars at the end of the 2016 season, progressing from the Low–A Auburn Doubledays up to the Single–A Hagerstown Suns over the course of his campaign.

[16] After fellow infielder Adrián Sánchez was optioned to the Triple–A Fresno Grizzlies following the final spring training game,[17] the Nationals selected Noll's contract and promoted him to the roster for Opening Day.

In his third major league at-bat, on April 3, he worked a bases-loaded walk against Philadelphia Phillies reliever David Robertson for a walk-off win in the ninth inning.

The Nationals finished the 2019 year 93–69, clinching a wild card spot, and eventually winning the World Series over the Houston Astros.

[23] Noll spent the entirety of the 2021 season with the Triple–A Rochester Red Wings, playing in 119 contests and batting .300/.346/.494 with 17 home runs and 69 RBI.