In July 2013, Wagoner became a senior planner for the City of Caldwell, Idaho.
[2] Wagoner was one of five candidates running for Caldwell, Idaho Mayor in the November 2021 election.
[3] Wagoner even though he was the highest vote getting with 47% of the vote,[4] Caldwell requires the mayoral race to win with more than 50% making Wagoner face John McGee on the November 30, 2021 run off election.
[12][13][14] Wagoner was defeated by Julie Yamamoto in the Republican primary, gaining only 41.73% of the vote.
[17] Wagoner challenged Brandon Hixon in the Republican primary, he lost taking only 48.5% of the vote.