Crafts was selected by the Indianapolis Colts in the 11th round (292nd pick overall) of the 1991 NFL draft, but was released during the preseason on August 16.
[1][2] After not making the Colts' roster, Crafts played for the Orlando Thunder of the World League of American Football (WLAF) in the spring of 1992.
In the AFL, he played for the New Jersey Red Dogs (2000), Buffalo Destroyers (2001–2002),[6] Las Vegas Gladiators (2003), and Detroit Fury (2004).
Crafts was a member for the Toronto Argonauts (2000–2001), Montreal Alouettes (2002, a year the team would go on to win the Grey Cup), and Hamilton Tiger Cats (2002) of the CFL.
He spent one season as offensive line coach with the National Arena League's Jacksonville Sharks, helping them win NALBowl I.