The Washington Post named Hubbard to the 1993 All-Met Boys' Lacrosse First Team as a midfielder after he led the IAC in goals with 59 as a junior.

[3] Then, when as a senior Hubbard became the All-time IAC goal scorer with 217, they named him the 1994 All-Met Boys' Lacrosse Team Player of the Year.

[5] Hubbard became was part of a trio of revered attackmen who were Princeton classmates along with Jon Hess and Chris Massey.

[9] In 1996, he earned co-Ivy League Player of the year by recording six or more goals four times during the regular season.

[18] In the 1996 NCAA Division I Men's Lacrosse Championship tournament quarterfinals 22–6 victory over Towson State, Hubbard again scored six goals.

[20] In the 1997 NCAA Division I Men's Lacrosse Championship tournament quarterfinals, he again scored six goals in an 11–9 victory over the UMass.

[25] He scored three goals in the 1998 NCAA Division I Men's Lacrosse Championship tournament 11–10 semifinal victory over Syracuse.

[30] He was named number 11 of the top 20 athletes in Princeton Tiger history by the Daily Princetonian.

[1] Hubbard also played in the National Lacrosse League for the Baltimore Thunder (1999), Pittsburgh CrosseFire (2000) and Washington Power (2001).

[39] When the MLL began its first season in 2001, Hubbard was instrumental in marketing the league looking to showcase premium talent.

[47] The MLL schedule was reduced from 14 games to 12 in 2003, meaning that Hubbard's 50 goals is the record for a 12-game season.

[2] Andy was a midfielder on the 1992 and 1994 teams that earned Princeton's first two NCAA Men's Lacrosse Championships.