[2] In 2011, Nealis went on to be named Third Team All-BIG EAST as he started all 18 games he appeared in and helped the Hoyas defense to seven shutouts.
[3] In his senior year in 2012, Nealis started all 26 games and led the Hoyas to the 2012 College Cup final where they eventually fall to Indiana 1–0.
[5] During his time in College, Nealis also played for Long Island Rough Riders in the USL Premier Development League.
[11] He made his professional debut a week later in a 1–0 victory over Atlanta Silverbacks in the final game of the 2013 NASL Fall Season.
[12] Nealis made his first appearance of the 2014 season on May 31, 2014, earning the start at left back and contributing to a 3–0 shutout road victory over the Fort Lauderdale Strikers.