According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, Catholic Family News is classified as a hate group for their adherence to integralism and the alleged antisemitism and other conspiracy theories.

Catholic Family News has a close relationship with Marcel Lefebvre's Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).

In June 2018, shortly after becoming editor-in-chief, McCall interviewed Niklaus Pfluger, First General Assistant of SSPX.

In April 2019, McCall was one of nineteen original signatories to an "open letter" accusing Pope Francis of heresy.

Articles have appeared on Sister Annella Zervas, O.S.B.,[6] Blessed Theodore Romzha, Mother Agnes Hart,[7] and Father Leo Heinrichs, O.F.M.