[1] He returned to his home state in 2004, accepting a position as quarterbacks coach for the LIU Post Pioneers.
[2] In his second season, Gill helped Rob Blount earn the conference player of the year award.
In 2009, Erik Anderwkavich received All-Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference honors under Gill.
He remained in that position until 2021, when he was promoted to head coach after Bryan Collins resigned.
[3] LIU started the season with a record of 0–5 before earning their first win against Central Connecticut on October 23.