As a sophomore in 1999, he led the Mules in wins (11), strikeouts (67) and innings pitched (87.0), on his way to being named First Team All-MIAA.
Reynolds pitched for the St. Lucie Mets of the Class A-Advanced Florida State League in 2001, finishing the year with a 4.95 ERA in 11 games started.
He would spend the 2003 season split between the Lake Elsinore Storm and the Sarasota Red Sox, posting a 4.07 ERA in 26 games, mostly a reliever.
Reynolds decided to give up playing, and took a graduate assistant job with the Kansas State Wildcats.
After just a single season with Northeast Texas, he joined the coaching staff of the Evansville Purple Aces.