Butters was born in Los Angeles, California, to parents Lorelei and Darrin; her father is a Disney animator who has worked on films such as Frozen and Ralph Breaks the Internet.

[3] In 2016, Butters portrayed the recurring role of Ella in the Amazon Prime Video series Transparent.

[4] Later that year, she began starring in the ABC sitcom American Housewife as Anna-Kat Otto.

[5] When Quentin Tarantino was writing the script of his ninth film Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, he spotted Butters on television, and later cast her in the role of precocious child actress Trudi Fraser.

[6] After she received critical acclaim for this role, Butters decided to pursue similar opportunities, leading her to leave American Housewife after four seasons.