[2] Killmer starred in the short-lived Hulu original reality web series If I Can Dream in 2010, which featured five aspiring actors and actresses who were trying to make it in the entertainment business by living together in a Los Angeles home, fitted with cameras following their every move, “The goal is to get a job that will allow us to get out of the house and to move on to a bigger career.
This is just the first step.”[2][1][3] In 2014, Killmer was cast as Athena True in the NBC science fiction crime thriller pilot Tin Man,[4] but it was not picked up by the network when it announced its 2014–15 television schedule.
[5] That same year, Killmer joined the cast of the NBC drama Chicago Fire as Sylvie Brett, the paramedic who replaces Leslie Shay (Lauren German) in the third season premiere titled "Always" that aired on September 23, 2014.
[7] Killmer made her feature film debut with her future husband Andrew Cheney and John Rhys-Davies in the Revolutionary War action-adventure thriller Beyond the Mask that was released on April 6, 2015.
[8] On May 14, 2016, Killmer married her Beyond the Mask co-star Andrew Cheney, whom she met on August 27, 2012, on the set of the film.