She would not return to the national championship until 2003, when she was the fifth player for skip Nancy McConnery.

[1] In 2004 and 2005 Hennigar played second for Team Nova Scotia at the Canadian Senior Championships with skip Sue Anne Bartlett.

Hennigar again played second, this time for skip Colleen Pinkney, at the 2009 Canadian Senior Curling Championships in Summerside, PEI.

After only losing one game in the round robin Hennigar and Team Nova Scotia defeated British Columbia 6-4 in the final to win the gold medal.

[2] Hennigar and her team then went on to represent Canada at the 2010 World Senior Curling Championships in Chelyabinsk, Russia where they beat Switzerland in the final to take home Canada's 6th World Senior Curling Championship title.