He made his first-class debut for Uttar Pradesh in the 2017–18 Ranji Trophy on 6 October 2017,[3] a month before he turned 17.

The right-arm pacer impressed one and all with his ability to move the ball around with good pace during the tournament.

[10] On 26 October 2020, Tyagi was named as one of four additional bowlers to travel with Indian cricket team for their tour to Australia.

[11] On 21 September 2021, Tyagi conceded just one run in the final over against Punjab Kings while defending four, and was named man of the match.

[12] In February 2022, he was bought by the Sunrisers Hyderabad in the auction for the 2022 Indian Premier League tournament.