During her time with the Boston University Terriers, the program would win four consecutive Hockey East championships (2012–15).
In the aftermath of the 2015 Hockey East tournament, Tutino joined Shannon Doyle and captain Marie-Philip Poulin on the All-Tournament Team.
[4] On April 25, 2017, Tutino was traded to the Les Canadiennes de Montréal in exchange for Nachi Fujimoto.
[6][7] Tutino returned on ice for the Italian Hockey League Women team HC Lakers for the season 2024-2025.
[9] During the season 2023-2024, she was named video coach of the Italy women's national ice hockey team.