Ahead of the Fall season, former MLS All-Star José Burciaga Jr. was brought on as team General Manager.

[4][5] In July 2019, the UPSL welcomed FORO Soccer Club out of Dallas, Texas as a new member of the Central Conference.

The team's first season under the new name saw it win the Central Conference's North Division for a first time with a near undefeated record.

[9] The team beat fellow UPSL side Alamo City SC in the fourth qualifying round to officially clinch a spot in the 2024 U.S. Open Cup.

[10] In the First Round of the tournament proper, FORO earned its first win over a professional team when it beat Austin FC II of MLS Next Pro, 2–2 (3–4 in penalty kicks).