The station was located north of Kelly's Corners between New York State Route 30 and the railroad tracks, just opposite the cemetery.
When it was first built, it was nothing but a board-and-batten flag stop and a place for local farmers to drop off milk.
In addition to the station, the railroad also maintained a section house and a coal pocket here.
There is documentation that the Yankee Creamery was a joint venture between Hanford S. Shultis, owner of "Elgin of the Catskills" dairy farm, and E. Louis Kadans, owner of Kadan's Creamery in Dunraven, New York.
When New York State rebuilt Route 30 in the 1960s they razed the station along with several other houses and barns in the area.