Neumann briefly played collegiate women's ice hockey for Clarkson University and SUNY Plattsburgh in the NCAA.
Over her three years at NAHA, she achieved a career GAA of 1.16, a save percentage of .930, and amassed 54 shutouts, and holds the program record for shut-outs in a season.
Prior to NAHA, she was a member of the Madison Capitals Bantam AAA boys’ team that participated at Nationals.
[3] Prior to joining the Buffalo Beauts, Neumann played for the USA Hockey National Bound,[4] North Carolina Women's hockey team, winning 1 National title and 1 second place title.
[7] In June 2017, it was announced that she had signed a one-year contract to play for the Buffalo Beauts in the 2017/18 NWHL season.