He never quite lived up to early expectations of being the next great Australian leg spin bowler, taking 53 wickets at an average of 38.07.
Recalled for the vital Seventh Test on the spinning SCG pitch he took 3/48 and 3/96, but it was not enough to win the game and save The Ashes.
O'Keeffe said that the umpire's comment was a sarcastic jibe at his inability to spin the ball, something he likes to mock himself about.
O'Keeffe has remained involved in cricket since his retirement, including as a commentator on ABC Radio.
He is known for his humorous anecdotes, told in the manner of an after-dinner speech at a cricketers club, and his distinctive laugh.