Together with guitarist Colin Kupson, Reynolds wrote and recorded her second EP, 2015's We Have No Future, We’re All Doomed with Jake Ewald of Modern Baseball and Slaughter Beach, Dog.

[2] The album, released on Soft Speak Records, was named after a friend's yearbook message, and ultimately became a memorial line after their death.

The result of these occupations was her debut full-length album Sunset Blush, named after a boxed wine she and her friends drank and their subsequent long, late-night conversations.

She recorded the album with friend Kyle Pulley of Thin Lips, who acted as a collaborator, at Headroom Studios in Philadelphia.

On October 8, 2020, Reynolds announced her signing to Triple Crown Records, alongside a new single called "Around Your Room".