In 1989, Schuler entered Northeastern University in Boston to pursue a bachelor's degree in cardiovascular health and exercise.

After her time at Northeastern, Schuler played for the Toronto Varsity Blues women's ice hockey program.

In the 1997 OWIAA semifinal, Schuler's hat trick led the Lady Blues to a 4-1 victory over the Guelph Gryphons.

Schuler would also score a goal against York University goaltender Debra Ferguson in the 1997 OWIAA gold medal game.

Schuler assisted head coach Ryan Walter for Team Canada at the 2010 Four Nations Cup.

[7] Schuler was an assistant coach for the Minnesota Duluth Bulldogs women's ice hockey program from 2008 until 2016.

On April 22, 2016, Schuler was named head coach of the Dartmouth College women's ice hockey team.

[10] On July 11, 2024, she was named the third head coach in the history of the Bulldogs women's ice hockey team.