The Laurelton station was originally built by the Long Island Rail Road in April 1907.

[4] The tracks were laid below grade level, and a floral arrangement on the embankment spelled out the community's name.

[4] On November 26, 1941, the eastbound facilities were relocated south in anticipation of a proposed grade crossing elimination project, but they were relocated north again on April 10, 1942, when the project was cancelled due to World War II.

[4][5] All facilities were again relocated south of the former location between November 16–18, 1948, when the aforementioned grade crossing elimination project was revived after the end of the war.

[6] It underwent further renovations between 2018 and 2019, during which time it received upgraded features such as LED lighting, repainted canopies, and improved staircases.