[1] Leadgate Park entered the FA Cup for the first time in 1892, receiving a bye in the first qualifying round in place of Sunderland Albion.

However, the application was unsuccessful as Crook Town and Darlington St Augustine's were chosen to replace Howden-le-Wear.

[6] Leadgate Park attained their highest league finishes in 1906–07 and 1911–12, placing fourth out of 12 teams.

In the same season, the team reached the fifth qualifying round of the FA Cup for the first time, but were knocked out by West Stanley.

In 1925, having conceded over 100 goals in 38 matches, Leadgate Park left the North Eastern League and subsequently disbanded.