In his subsequent church career, he followed the way opened when his brother James Pilkington became Bishop of Durham.
When Mary I of England came to the throne, he was deprived of his college positions, and left the country.
[1][2] He returned to England and was restored to his fellowship at St John's, his wife having died.
He became Master there in 1561, replacing his brother James and initiating a period of divisive governance and an effort to reform the college by replacing Catholic associations with the Protestantism of Geneva.
He brought in William Fulke as Fellow, and ensured the succession of Richard Longworth, and then resigned as Master.