He was said to have legally obtained the house (now a ruin) but to have maintained his group of cattle through the theft of strays from neighbours.
Hutchinson murdered for pure sport, what may be described as a thrill killing, as passers-by from all races, shapes, sizes, and incomes were fair game.
This is why he was allowed to roam free for a time until he shot an English soldier by the name of John Calendar, who attempted to apprehend Hutchinson.
Although the final toll is unknown, upon searching his home after his arrest, approximately 43 watches and a large amount of clothing was found.
Planter James Walker and Roger Maddix were sentenced to death for participating in the murder of farmer William Lickley and schoolmaster Timothy Cronin.