In 2017, she was part of the ensemble cast of the drama Novitiate and in 2018 she starred in the comedy Banana Split.

In 2023, she would appear in Scream VI, Totally Killer, the Peacock comedy thriller series Based on a True Story, and Criminal Minds (2024).

[2] In 2005, Liberato made her acting debut in the television series Cold Case and has appeared on Sons of Anarchy, CSI: Miami.

The following year she appeared in the fourth season of House,[3] and was featured in the June issue of The New York Times Magazine.

[3] In 2007, Liberato obtained the leading role in the 20th Century Fox adventure film The Last Sin Eater.