All Awards were voted for by the head coaches of each MAAC member team.
[1] All Awards were discontinued after the conclusion of the 2002-03 season when the MAAC ice hockey conference was dissolved due to Fairfield and Iona discontinuing their Division I programs.
All remaining schools formed Atlantic Hockey which began play the following year.
Sources:[2][3] The all-conference teams are composed of one goaltender, two defencemen and three forwards.
Should a tie occur for the final selection at any position, both players will be included as part of the superior team with no reduction in the number of players appearing on any succeeding teams (as happened in 1998–99 and 1999–00).