On the night Sarah is to babysit Jane with Ethan and Benny, Rory accidentally ruins the cable, leaving the 5 of them bored.
After dismissing it, Rory plays alone and breaks the rules of the game, causing a demon spirit to unleash.
The boys dig up the Cubile Animus and successfully suck the demon out of Sarah, just before Ethan's parents come home.
However, all is not well when, unknown to the boys, a hand pokes out from the spot where they dug up the box, implying that Jesse has awakened from his grave.
[2] After Ethan, Benny, and Sarah boast about being able to handle their adventures on their own, they each wake up alone, trapped in separate dimensions where they must face their own fears.
Sarah's fear is becoming an evil, bloodthirsty vampire, Benny's is a psychotic dentist robot from a scary movie, and Ethan is chased by a cloaked figure.
However, Ethan was supposed to be alone in his dimension, as his fear is losing his friends; Benny's grandma had not summoned any cloaked creature.
In part 1 of the 2-part series finale, Ethan discovers through a vision that the Cloaked Attacker from episode "Independence Daze" is after the Lucifractor, something greatly feared.
Benny and Rory work together to find the Lucifractor during Ethan's dinner date with Sarah at a vampire restaurant.
Ethan is dragged into a telepathic link with Jesse, who tells him the purpose of the Lucifractor: to drain dark energy, including what is needed to keep vampires alive.
He brings it to school with him to safeguard it but the weapon is taken by Vice Principal Stern, who places it in a box with the same symbol as the one on the Attacker's cloak.
In part 2 of the 2-part series finale, Ethan has a vision in which Stern tells him that he plans to use the Lucifractor to take back Whitechapel from the vampires who stole the town and the weapon from his family.