Awarding the album three stars from CCM Magazine, Matt Conner states, some of the songs "will become...favorite[s]".

Bert Gangl, rating the album two and a half stars for Jesus Freak Hideout, Bert Gangl writes, "its overly homogenous musical palette and similarity to the OSS cooperative's previous work unfortunately renders it largely superfluous.

"[4] Giving the album four stars for Indie Vision Music, Jonathan Andre says, "Jason, Paul and Stu G. have developed one of the most honest, transparent and satisfying worship experiences".

[3] Dave Wood, awarding the album five stars from Louder Than the Music, describes, "they do it with an abundance of class along the way.

"[5] Rating the album a four and a half stars at Christian Music Zine, Joshua Andre states, "With a smorgasboard of new melodies and long time fan favourites; Live At the Tracking Room will have you singing along- it is one of the best worship albums since albums from Paul Baloche, Christy Nockels, and Passion!