[1] According to Trouser Press's David Sprague, Love Child was "...one of Gotham's most mercurial bands, able to leap from twee pop tunes to galvanizing skronkadelic constructs in a single bound.
a B+ grade, writing, "Too bad these punk-going-no-wave neotraditionalists didn't study their Ramones harder--instead of crowding 21 songs into 45 minutes, they might have grouped the 14 snappiest into a dandy 27-minute shot in the dark.
"[1] Nils Bernstein gave Witchcraft a favorable review in Spin, praising Rebecca Odes as having "one of those casually classic voices such as Kim Deal's, immediately familiar and utterly inimitable.
"[7] Jason Cherkis of the Daily Collegian also reviewed the album favorably, writing, "On Witchcraft, the group doesn't twist but glides, forming perfect underground nursery rhymes without putting you to sleep.
"[8] Jason Ankeny of AllMusic gave the album four out of five stars, describing it as "Another wonderful record from one of the most criminally overlooked bands of the early '90s.