Jason Pettigrew, writing for Alt Press, said that Love Is Ain't Dead "continues to deliver sonic wonderment and some much-needed personal redemption".

[2] Damon Taylor, writing for Dead Press, gave the album a 7 out of 10, saying that '68 "delves deeper into distorted melodies and sludgy grooves, the record continues to cement the disruptive and frantic take on blues that the duo has become known for.

[4] Lewandowski said the EP has "experimental sounds and bold rhythms are certainly not the mark of traditional rock, but it’s clear from the beginning that ’68 was aiming for something a bit more abstract.

"[4] Lewandowski summarized the EP with, "in all that electric distortion and “raw nerve,” the band delivers with complete control.

With only four songs on the EP, each track creates a gradual-yet-immediate unraveling of traditional hardcore, doubling down on the claims of their juxtaposition.