[3] Schiffel attended the University of San Francisco and played for the Dons in the West Coast Conference (WCC).

In 2013, Schiffel played every minute in goal for USF and was named an All-West Coast Conference Team honorable mention.

In her senior year, Schiffel was named to the preseason All-WCC team and earned first-team NSCAA All-West Region honors.

[3] After Schiffel was selected 34th overall by the Washington Spirit in the NWSL College Draft in January 2016, she signed with Norwegian club Avaldsnes IL.

[11] The team had previously acquired her player rights from Washington Spirit in November 2016 as part of a trade that included Christine Nairn and Havana Solaun.