The song is a calm and mellow dance-pop and synthpop track, which features instrumentation of synthesizers and keyboards.

"Magic of Love" received positive reviews from music critics, whom complimented the song's production and composition.

As with the rest of Level3, Japanese producer and Capsule musician Yasutaka Nakata had written, arranged and composed the song.

[6] Writing for Land of Rising, Alex Shenmue commented that its "mellow mood will be there for most of the track’s length, replacing the more instrumentally complex parts and offering a calmer and slightly melancholic feeling, [...]".

"[11] Ian Martin, who had written their extended biography at Allmusic, had highlighted the song as an album and career standout.

[12] Konno Asami from nihongogo.com praised the outcome after the release of Perfume's "childish" single "Mirai no Museum", stating "it’s a fun song with a great dance and funny lyrics.

[6] "Magic of Love" was used as in TV commercials of Pure Gummy by Kanro (the second song used for advertising this product after "Communication").

[20] The official music video was directed by Japanese director Yusuke Tanaka and premiered on Perfume's YouTube channel in June 2013.