Claiborne was shot and killed the same year in a dispute with the messenger sent by the Georgia House, Moses H. Bentley,[1] who had been a black delegate to the Constitutional Convention,[2] in a heated dispute over the pay of House pages.
[3][4] According to the Atlanta Historical Bulletin, Claiborne was shot and killed on Marietta Street near Forsyth Street, after a heated argument where Claiborne accused Bentley of wrongly firing a Black page and replacing him with a White page.
The article said the dispute was reportedly due to "opprobrious remarks" made by Claiborne towards Bentley in relation to Claiborne condemning Bentley for his actions which caused the arrest of Senator Wallace.
[6] Claiborne is believed to be buried at the Oakland Cemetery (Atlanta), although the exact location of his grave is unknown.
[7] A bronze sculpture was placed at the Georgia state capitol to honor Claiborne and the other legislators who were expelled because of their color.