As a senior at University High School, Magro earned All-State honors as he helped lead his team to a 9-3 record and the second round of the West Virginia playoffs.
As Henry was injured in the game against East Carolina, Magro made nine tackles, two sacks, and forced two fumbles.
He had a key seven-yard sack in the victory over UConn and in the 2006 Sugar Bowl, he had two tackles and recovered a fumble against the Georgia.
He earned the Ideal Mountaineer Man Award at the end of the season from head coach Rich Rodriguez.
Magro earned the starting job in 2007 at middle linebacker, playing alongside Mortty Ivy and Reed Williams.
[1] In his final collegiate game, the 2008 Fiesta Bowl win over Oklahoma, he recorded four tackles.
His 28 bench reps was one of the top for any prospect for the 2008 NFL draft on their respective Pro Day workout.
[4][6] He was released from the practice squad on September 24 when wide receiver Matt Caddell was re-signed.
The team released linebacker Tyson Smith to make room for Magro on the practice squad.