She was one of the most famous Shakespearean actresses in the 1880s, although her reputation arose as much from clever publicity as from her skill.
Heavy advance publicity guaranteed a large turnout, but response to her performance was mixed.
She was a manifest failure as Joan of Arc in a translation of Jules Barbier's play on that subject in 1890.
The production, at Wallack's Theatre,[1] was lavish, costing forty thousand dollars, but it failed; the play was too little-known to attract large audiences, and Mather herself was judged too emotional to succeed in the role.
[3] Mather was buried in a white gown from her role as Juliet on Easter Sunday.