[4] In 1967, Toole won her first provincial women's championship, throwing third rocks on the Elizabeth MacDonald rink.

[6] In 1969, Toole won her second provincial women's championship, skippig a rink of Jennie Boomhower, Mary Acorn and Pauline Johnston.

[2] At the 1971 Canadian Ladies Curling Association Championship, she led PEI to a 5–4 record, tied for fourth.

[10] In 1974, Toole with her team of Boomhower, Dillon and Johnston won her sixth title, and fourth with that line up.

[2] At the 1974 Macdonald Lassies Championship, Toole led Prince Edward Island to a second-place finish, with a 7–2 record.